Backyard BBQs are a summer staple in Buffalo, NY, and nothing brings the heat like the best gas grills. When the snow finally melts and the smell of fresh-cut grass fills the air, there’s no better time to fire up a grill and enjoy sizzling steaks, juicy burgers, and grilled veggies with friends and family.
At Gary Pools & Leisure, we know that choosing among the best gas grills can be overwhelming, especially with Buffalo’s unpredictable weather. This comprehensive guide for best gas grills in Buffalo, breaks down everything you need to know to choose the right barbecue grill, including product comparisons, local insights, and top brand recommendations.
Let’s fire it up!
Understanding Best Gas Grills: What You Need to Know Before You Buy
Let’s break down what separates the best gas grills from the rest, whether you’re a casual cook or a backyard BBQ pro.
Gas grills are the go-to option for convenience, speed, and consistent cooking. But not all gas grills are built the same. Before diving into specific models, let’s explore the key types and features that separate a good grill from a great one.
Types of Gas Grills
Propane vs. Natural Gas:
- Propane grills are more portable and can be used anywhere.
- Natural gas grills offer lower long-term fuel costs but require a fixed gas line.
- Tip: In Buffalo, propane is usually preferred due to its flexibility and the option to store tanks over winter.
When hunting for the best gas grills, keep in mind portability vs. cost—propane wins for on-the-go flexibility in Buffalo.
Infrared Grills: These grills use radiant heat rather than convection. Perfect for high-heat searing and faster cooking times.
Key Features to Consider
The best gas grills often strike a balance of BTU power, cooking area, and build quality—exactly what Buffalo grillers need.
- BTU Rating: This measures heat output. Look for 75–100 BTUs per square inch of cooking area for optimal performance.
- Cooking Surface Area: Think about how many people you typically cook for. 400–500 sq. inches is great for most families.
- Materials: Choose stainless steel or enameled cast iron grates for durability and easy cleanup.
Top Gas Grill Brands Available in Buffalo, NY
Living in Buffalo means your grill has to handle intense winters and humid summers. At Gary Pools & Leisure, we’ve curated a collection of brands that meet these demands with strength and style.
Broilmaster Gas Grills
Offered locally by Gary Pools & Leisure, Broilmaster is all about performance and reliability. It’s been called the “grill of a lifetime” for good reason.
Why Buffalo loves Broilmaster:
- Thick cast aluminum hoods resist corrosion.
- Optional rotisserie kits for versatile outdoor cooking.
- Wide cooking zones and side burners.
Evaluating the Best Gas Grills for Buffalo’s Climate
Buffalo weather doesn’t play nice. That’s why your grill needs to work hard and last long. Let’s break down what makes a grill Buffalo-ready.
Weather Resistance
Choose grills with:
- Powder-coated steel or stainless steel finishes.
- Double-lined hoods to lock in heat even on breezy evenings.
- High-quality grill covers for protection from rain, snow, and salt air.
Cold-Weather Performance
- Electric ignitions are more reliable in cold temps than push-button piezos.
- Look for models with ceramic briquettes or heat diffusers to maintain consistent internal temperatures.
Buffalo-Friendly Tip:
Buy from a local retailer like Gary’s to get service, parts, and expert setup, which is especially important when winterizing your gear.
Local Retailers & Showrooms That Know BBQ
Gary Pools & Leisure: Your One-Stop Grill Shop
At Gary’s, we offer:
- Top-tier brands like Broilmaster.
- In-store experts who help you compare models based on your lifestyle.
- Locations in Amherst, Cheektowaga, and Clarence.
- Plus: We’re not just about grills, we do hot tubs, patio furniture, and full backyard makeovers.
Why Shop Local?
- Get hands-on with display models.
- Ask our BBQ pros your toughest cooking questions.
- Access parts, customer service, and delivery.
Product Roundup: Best Gas Grills at Gary Pools & Leisure
Our selection of the best gas grills at Gary Pools & Leisure offers unmatched durability, heat control, and climate readiness. We offer a hand-picked selection of grills that stand up to Buffalo’s weather, deliver top-tier outdoor cooking performance, and offer long-term durability.
Here’s a closer look at the four best gas grills, complete with product overviews, standout features, and who each grill is best suited for.
| Grill Model | Brand | Fuel Type | Cooking Area | Top Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H3X Deluxe | Broilmaster | Propane / Natural Gas | 695 sq. in. | Dual stainless burners, multi-level grids, rotisserie option, smoker shutter | All-around backyard grilling & entertaining |
| P4X Premium | Broilmaster | Propane / Natural Gas | 473 sq. in. | Smoker shutter, H-style burner, cast aluminum, side burner & rotisserie options | Precision cooking and multi-zone grilling |
| H4X | Broilmaster | Propane / Natural Gas | 473 sq. in. | Stainless steel H-style burner, stainless steel control panel, chrome-plated warming rack, and electric ignition | Everyday living and enjoyment with loved ones |
| P3X | Broilmaster | Propane / Natural Gas | 695 sq. in. | Two three-level grids, griddle, control panel, smoker shutter, folding retract-a-rack, and adjustable lid stop. | Hosting family and friends alike for delicious backyard BBQs and parties |
Broilmaster H3X Gas Grill – The Backyard Workhorse
Product Overview:
The Broilmaster H3X is designed for serious grillers who demand performance, durability, and versatility. Crafted with heavy-duty cast aluminum and a sleek black enamel finish, it offers exceptional heat retention and corrosion resistance, perfect for Buffalo’s four-season climate.
Key Features:
- 40,000 BTUs across two stainless steel burners.
- 695 square inches of total cooking area with multi-level grates.
- Adjustable stainless steel cooking grids and dual-control knobs.
- Optional rotisserie kit and smoker shutter for added versatility.
- Push-button electric ignition for consistent lighting—even in cold weather.
What It’s Best For:
The H3X is a fantastic choice for homeowners looking to grill everything from steak and pork ribs to delicate vegetables. Its size and feature set make it ideal for both weeknight meals and weekend BBQ parties.
Broilmaster P4X Gas Grill – Precision Meets Durability
Product Overview:
The P4X is Broilmaster’s flagship premium gas grill, known for its rugged build and precise temperature control. It brings restaurant-quality outdoor cooking right to your backyard.
Key Features:
- 40,000 BTU stainless steel H-style burner.
- 473 square inches of primary cooking space.
- Smoker shutter system lets you switch from direct to indirect heat instantly.
- Stainless steel control panel and heat indicators.
- Optional accessories include side burners, rotisserie, and warming racks.
What It’s Best For:
This model is ideal for serious BBQ lovers and culinary experimenters who want the flexibility to grill, roast, and smoke on one solid platform. The P4X handles everything from searing steaks to smoking tender pork shoulder.
Broilmaster H4X Deluxe Gas Grill — “The Classic Performer”
Product Overview:
The Broilmaster H4X Deluxe Gas Grill combines timeless design with reliable performance. Crafted with a heavy-duty cast aluminum grill head, it offers a durable and efficient grilling experience. Its single-level stainless steel cooking grids provide ample space for your grilling needs. The H-style burner delivers even heat distribution, ensuring consistent cooking results.
Key Features:
- Heavy-duty cast aluminum construction for durability
- 36,000 BTU stainless steel H-style burner
- 473 square inches of total cooking area
- Single-level stainless steel cooking grids
- Chrome-plated steel retract-a-rack for added cooking space
- Charmaster briquets for indirect cooking
- Electronic ignition for easy startup
What It’s Best For:
Ideal for those seeking a straightforward, durable grill that delivers consistent heat and reliable performance for everyday grilling.
Broilmaster P3X Premium Gas Grill — “The Versatile Entertainer”
Product Overview:
The Broilmaster P3X Premium Gas Grill is designed for those who desire versatility and high performance. Featuring a heavy-duty cast aluminum construction, it ensures longevity and efficient heat retention. The 40,000 BTU stainless steel Bow Tie burner provides exceptional heat distribution across its 695 square inches of cooking area.
Key Features:
- Heavy-duty cast aluminum construction
- 40,000 BTU stainless steel Bow Tie burner
- 695 square inches of total cooking area
- Multi-level stainless steel cooking grids
- Stainless steel folding retract-a-rack
- Ceramic briquettes for even heat distribution
- Stainless steel control panel with separate left and right controls
What It’s Best For:
Perfect for those who entertain frequently and require a grill that offers versatility, ample cooking space, and consistent heat for a variety of grilling techniques.
Budgeting Your Backyard BBQ Investment
No matter what your budget is, there are best gas grills at every price point—here’s how to find yours.
Entry-Level (Under $300)
- Ideal for casual use or small households.
- Simple propane grills with basic heat control.
- May lack extras like side burners or stainless finishes.
Mid-Range ($300–$700)
- A sweet spot for most families.
- Durable steel or cast aluminum construction.
- Built-in thermometers, shelves, and griddles.
Premium ($700+)
- Luxury performance for serious outdoor chefs.
- Add-ons: Rotisserie kits, infrared burners, ceramic heat tiles.
- Often made from marine-grade stainless steel or thick castings.
Must-Have Grill Accessories for BBQs
Once you’ve picked your grill, gear up for greatness with these essentials.
Essentials
- Grill cover: Shield your investment from snow and rain.
- Digital meat thermometer: Say goodbye to overcooked pork.
- Grill brush: Keep your metal grates clean and safe.
Add-Ons
- Rotisserie attachments for roasting chicken evenly.
- Griddles for smash burgers and breakfast skillets.
- Pizza stones to turn your kamado into an outdoor oven.
Grill Maintenance Tips to Extend Gas Grill Life
A high-quality gas grill is an investment – one that pays you back every time you enjoy perfectly grilled steak, smoky ribs, or veggies with that golden sear. But like any well-used tool, your grill needs regular maintenance to keep performing like new.
At Gary Pools & Leisure, we recommend these weekly, monthly, and seasonal maintenance routines to protect your grill from Buffalo’s intense climate and maximize its lifespan.
Weekly Maintenance
Clean the Cooking Grates After Every Use Right after you finish cooking, and while the grates are still warm, is the best time to give them a good scrub using a steel grill brush. This prevents food buildup and carbon from hardening and sticking.
Wipe Down Exterior Surfaces Use a stainless-steel-safe cleaner to keep your grill looking shiny and corrosion-free. This is especially important if your grill is exposed to Buffalo’s summer humidity or unexpected rainfall.
Empty the Grease Tray Neglecting the grease trap is a fire hazard waiting to happen. After a few sessions, check and clean it to prevent flare-ups and grease fires.
Monthly Maintenance
Check Burners for Blockages Grease and debris can clog burner ports, causing uneven heat. Remove the burners (if detachable), give them a quick cleaning, and make sure flames are burning blue and evenly.
Inspect Gas Lines and Connections Look for any cracks, leaks, or loose fittings. A quick way to test is the soap-and-water method: Mix soapy water, spray it on connections, and turn the gas on, if you see bubbles, there’s a leak.
Clean Heat Shields and Flame Tamers These components help distribute heat and protect burners from drippings. Remove them and scrape off any buildup.
Winter Storage in Buffalo
Buffalo winters aren’t just cold, they’re brutal. That means extra care is required to store your grill properly.
1. Disconnect the Propane Tank For safety and to prevent freezing damage, always remove your propane tank and store it upright outdoors, away from direct snow or moisture.
2. Store the Grill Indoors (If Possible) A shed, garage, or enclosed patio is ideal. If left outside, use a heavy-duty, waterproof cover made from UV-resistant materials to prevent rust and corrosion.
3. Apply Cooking Oil to the Grates Lightly coat clean grates with a high-heat cooking oil like canola or grapeseed oil. This protects them from rust and keeps them seasoned for the next BBQ season.
4. Seal Off Entry Points Mice and insects sometimes make winter homes inside unused grills. Seal vent openings with breathable material and check inside before first use in spring.
Safety First: Grill Without the Thrills (of a Fire Hazard)
While grilling is one of summer’s greatest joys, it comes with real risks, especially when handling flammable gas, high heat, and pressurized fuel. Follow these essential safety rules to keep every BBQ fun and accident-free.
Safe Setup Guidelines
- Keep the Grill 10 Feet Away from Structures – Never grill under eaves, close to vinyl siding, or on wooden porches. A single flare-up can cause serious damage in seconds
- Use a Flat, Stable Surface – Make sure your grill is placed on a level concrete or paver patio. Avoid grass or mulch, which can shift and pose fire risks.
Lighting & Operating Safely
- Always Open the Lid Before Igniting – Gas buildup in a closed lid can cause dangerous flare-ups or explosions. Always open the hood before lighting the grill
- Stay Close and Focused While Cooking Unattended grills are the number one cause of backyard fires. Stay nearby, and keep a fire extinguisher or bucket of sand within arm’s reach, just in case.
Gas Leak Detection
Use the Soap & Water Method Monthly – Mix a solution of dish soap and water, then apply it to all gas fittings and lines. Open the valve – and keep in mind that bubbles mean leaks. If detected, shut off the supply immediately and replace damaged components.
What NOT to Do
- Never grill indoors, even in a garage with the door open.
- Avoid using extension hoses not rated for outdoor grills.
- Don’t store propane tanks inside enclosed spaces.
Pro Tip: If anything seems off, such as strange smells, weak flames, or delayed ignition, consult your user manual or contact the experts at Gary Pools & Leisure for service.
FAQs: What Customers Ask Most
1. What’s the best grill for year-round use in Buffalo?
The best gas grills ideal for Buffalo’s harsh winters are Broilmaster with cast aluminum construction.
2. Is natural gas cheaper than propane?
Yes, in the long term. But it requires a permanent hookup and is less flexible for moving your grill.
3. Can I add a rotisserie later?
Many high-end grills like the Broilmaster H3X support rotisserie kits that can be installed post-purchase.
4. How often should I deep clean my grill?
Once every 2-3 months, depending on use. Check burners and clean grease traps regularly.
Final Thoughts: Your Grill, Your Backyard Hero
Choosing the best gas grill for your backyard BBQs in Buffalo isn’t just about BTUs or burners – it’s about building memories with every sizzle. Gary Pools & Leisure is here to help you make the right choice.
Visit one of our showrooms or shop online to see the best gas grills in action—and get personalized recommendations for your backyard setup.
Let’s make this BBQ season your best yet!
